Tuesday, 27 January 2015
Two out of every five civilians killed in 2014 could have been saved by a No-Fly Zone
• 42% of all civilians killed in 2014 were victims of Assad air attacks.
Of 17,582 civilians confirmed killed in 2014, 7,559 were recorded killed by air attacks according to the Violations Documentation Center in Syria. 163 of those were killed by the US-led Coalition air attacks, meaning 7,396 were killed by Regime air attacks: 42% of all civilians killed.
That minimum number of civilians killed in Syria in under four months by the US-led Coalition is now greater than the number of civilians killed by NATO’s seven month campaign in Libya (40 to 115). Unlike NATO’s Libya campaign, the US-led air campaign in Syria is not primarily intended to protect civilians.
• Over 95% of all the people killed by Assad air attacks in 2014 were civilians.
Total deaths by air attacks confirmed by the VDC in 2014 amounted to 7,954 people of which 227 were killed by the US-led Coalition, meaning 7,727 were killed by Assad regime air strikes. Only 395 were combatants, just under 5% of the overall total. 64 of those combatants were killed by the US-led Coalition, leaving 331 combatants killed by Assad regime air attacks,
For 2014, VDC list 17,369 civilians killed under ‘martyrs’ and 213 civilians killed under ‘regime’. VDC numbers are minimum counts of confirmed violent deaths and are likely to be significantly lower than the true totals. The UN minimum count up to the end of April 2014 shows over 80,000 more people killed than the VDC total for the same period.
Friday, 16 January 2015
Air attacks: 2014’s biggest killer of women and children
Over half the women and children killed in Syria last year could have been saved by a No-Fly Zone.
Of all violent deaths of women and children confirmed by the Violations Documentation Center in Syria, a majority were victims of attacks by Assad’s air force.
Of women killed, 50.9% were killed by Regime air attacks.
Of girls killed, 55.5% were killed by Regime air attacks.
Of boys killed, 50.6% were killed by Regime air attacks.
VDC numbers are a minimum count of confirmed killed, and show a major undercount when compared to UN minimum figures. They do however provide details on individual deaths not publicly available from other documenting groups. Their online database allows sorting by date, gender, cause of death, and more.
Below are the results from their database used to calculate the above percentages. Note that they list women and children both under “Martyrs” and “Regime fatalities”.
Adult women total victims: 1920+128=2048
Adult women victims of Regime air attacks: 1043
Adult women victims of Coalition air attacks: 2
Girl children total victims: 1144+91=1235
Girl children victims of Regime air attacks: 685
Girl children victims of Coalition air attacks: 5
Boy children total victims: 2384+150=2534
Boy children victims of Regime air attacks: 1283
Boy children victims of Coalition air attacks: 12
Thanks to Lopforum for inspiring this post.
Of all violent deaths of women and children confirmed by the Violations Documentation Center in Syria, a majority were victims of attacks by Assad’s air force.
Of women killed, 50.9% were killed by Regime air attacks.
Of girls killed, 55.5% were killed by Regime air attacks.
Of boys killed, 50.6% were killed by Regime air attacks.
VDC numbers are a minimum count of confirmed killed, and show a major undercount when compared to UN minimum figures. They do however provide details on individual deaths not publicly available from other documenting groups. Their online database allows sorting by date, gender, cause of death, and more.
Below are the results from their database used to calculate the above percentages. Note that they list women and children both under “Martyrs” and “Regime fatalities”.
Adult women total victims: 1920+128=2048
Adult women victims of Regime air attacks: 1043
Adult women victims of Coalition air attacks: 2
Girl children total victims: 1144+91=1235
Girl children victims of Regime air attacks: 685
Girl children victims of Coalition air attacks: 5
Boy children total victims: 2384+150=2534
Boy children victims of Regime air attacks: 1283
Boy children victims of Coalition air attacks: 12
Thanks to Lopforum for inspiring this post.
Thursday, 1 January 2015
The number of civilians killed in Syria since 2011 is greater than the number of British civilians killed in the Second World War
For the entire conflict, the Violations Documentation Center in Syria has recorded 78,867 civilians killed to date, greater than the recorded number of British civilians killed in the Second World War.
The VDC is unable to record all violent deaths. By comparing their numbers to the UN’s most recent minimum count, it appears the true figure of civilians violently killed in Syria since March 2011 may well be over 137,000. All violent deaths, civilian and military, are now well over 200,000.
The UN’s minimum count of 191,369 violent deaths to the end of April 2014 was greater than Iraq Body Count’s number for total violent deaths in Iraq in the ten years from 2003 to 2013: 174,000 including combatants.
The UN Security Council passed Resolution 2139 in February of last year, demanding amongst other measures an end to aerial bombing of civilian areas. Enforcement of the resolution has been blocked by permanent member Russia, the principle supplier of arms and aircraft to Assad’s air force.
Individual states enjoying the privilege of UN Security Council membership now have a responsibility to act: specifically France, the United Kingdom, and the United States. These three states have the proven ability to stop the Assad regime’s air attacks against civilians almost immediately. Their New Year’s resolution should now be to enforce the old year’s resolution.
Action is justified, in the words used by then Defence Minister George Robertson in the 1999 Parliamentary debate on the UK’s Kosovo intervention, “as an exceptional measure in support of purposes laid down by the UN Security Council, but without the Council's express authorisation.” Whether individually or collectively, France, the United Kingdom, and the United States, must act now to stop this slaughter.
Protect civilians. Enforce UN Security Council Resolution 2139. Syria needs a No-Fly Zone.
• Photo: Firemen at work in bomb damaged street in London, after Saturday night raid, circa 1941. Source: US National Archives.
Wednesday, 31 December 2014
A New Year’s resolution: enforce the old year’s resolution
Since March 2011, when protests began against the dictatorship in Syria, hundreds of thousands of Syrians have been killed. Many thousands of those killed, likely tens of thousands of them, were killed by regime air attacks using planes and helicopters dropping conventional bombs, barrel bombs, and chlorine chemical weapons. Many thousands more, adults and children, have been maimed.
As many as 95% of those killed in regime air attacks have been civilians.
In February 2014, the United Nations Security Council passed Resolution 2139 which included the demand “that all parties immediately cease all attacks against civilians, as well as the indiscriminate employment of weapons in populated areas, including shelling and aerial bombardment, such as the use of barrel bombs, and methods of warfare which are of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering…”
UNSCR 2139 closed with the Security Council expressing “its intent to take further steps in the case of non-compliance,” but since then no action has been taken by the UNSC to stop the air attacks.
In the absence of further steps by the UNSC as a whole, and with UNSC permanent member Russia both arming Syria’s air force and also blocking collective UNSC action, individual states enjoying the privilege of permanent membership of the UNSC must take responsibility: specifically France, the United Kingdom, and the United States. These three states have the proven ability to stop the Assad regime’s air attacks against civilians almost immediately. Their New Year’s resolution should now be to enforce the old year’s resolution.
Action is justified, in the words used by George Robertson in the 1999 Parliamentary debate on the UK’s Kosovo intervention, “as an exceptional measure in support of purposes laid down by the UN Security Council, but without the Council's express authorisation.” Whether individually or collectively, France, the United Kingdom, and the United States, must act now to stop this slaughter.
Protect civilians. Enforce UN Security Council Resolution 2139. Syria needs a No-Fly Zone.
Background notes at hhttps://nfzsyria.blogspot.com/p/about.html
Tuesday, 30 December 2014
Minimum of 24,168 civilians killed since Commons vote – true number may be over 42,000
The Violations Documentation Center in Syria has now documented 24,168 civilians killed since the 29 August 2013 UK Parliament vote rejecting military intervention in Syria.
That vote was on a Government motion which raised the possibility of military action in response to a massive chemical weapons attack on civilians by the Assad regime; however the motion was clear that military action could only take place after a UN Security Council debate, and after a further vote in the House of Commons.
224 Members of Parliament of the opposition Labour Party, under the leadership of Ed Miliband, as well as 39 backbench coalition MPs and 22 other MPs, voted against the motion.
The figure of 24,168 civilians killed since is from the Violations Documentation Center online database, and may have been updated by the time you read this. The VDC are just one of the organisations collecting and verifying reports of deaths in Syria. They are not able to document every death.
The Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights has issued a series of reports on violent deaths in the Syria conflict by comparing information from a number of organisations on the ground, including the VDC. The most recent UN report covers the period from the start of protests in March 2011 up to the end of April 2014. It gave a minimum number of 191,369 confirmed violent deaths. According to the report, that number is “likely undercounting the true total number of conflict-related killings that have occurred during this time period.” For that same time period, the VDC was only able to document 109,531 confirmed violent deaths including regime deaths, just over half of the UN number. Therefore the VDC number is a significant undercount compared to the UN number, which itself is a minimum count and therefore an undercount by an unknown margin.
If the VDC undercount of civilian deaths for the period since the UK Parliament vote is of the same proportion as the undercount of all violent deaths for the period covered by the UN report, then the number of civilian deaths since the House of Commons vote is over 42,000.
For the entire conflict, the VDC has documented 78,819 civilians killed to date, greater than the recorded number of British civilians killed in the Second World War. By the same calculation of comparing to the UN count, the true figure of civilians violently killed in Syria since March 2011 is likely to be over 137,000. All violent deaths, civilian and military, are now well over 200,000.
None of these figures include war-related deaths caused by exposure, malnutrition, and destruction of medical services; more fallen sparrows than we can count.
Below are the 95 civilians that the Violations Documentation Center listed as killed in one day, Christmas Day, 2014.
| Unidentified 3 | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Maskaneh | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified 2 | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Maskaneh | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified 1 | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Maskaneh | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Hasan Ali al-Tahhan al-Noaemi | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Quneitra | 2014-12-25 | Shooting | |
| Abdul Salam al-Jahush | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Kanaker | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Alaa al-Rafea | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Quneitra | Rafeed | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Rifaa al-Hadhud | Civilian | Adult - Female | Homs | Der Baalba | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ameera Mohammad al-Khateeb | Civilian | Adult - Female | Idlib | Taftanaz | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ahmad Adnan Musa al-Khateeb | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Quneitra | Mashareh | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Hasan Ahmad al-Naqo | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Abdul Kader Faraj | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad Ali al-Hameed | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ibrahem Meho | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Majed Merash | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Khaleel Ali al-Ali | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Musa al-Hamood | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Hasan Abbas | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Muhammad Shukri | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Qasem Hesso | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Kheder Hesso | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mustafa Hmado al-Shehabi | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ahmad Hmado al-Shehabi | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Satouf al-Naqo | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ibrahem al-Mustafa | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bazzaa | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad Omar Mahmoud al-Jabali | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad Shasho | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Kabbasin | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad Abdul Baset Aboud | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ismael Khamees | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mustafa Kassar | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling | |
| Husain al-Nayef | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Waseem al-Ghawi | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Abdul Hameed al-Ghawi | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified | Civilian | Child - Male | Hama | Abo Fashafeesh village | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Khawla Mustafa al-Hallak | Civilian | Child - Female | Idlib | Habeet | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Hassan Adnan al-Rahmoon | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Jarjanaz | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Akram Abdulla Haj Qasem | Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Saraqib | 2014-12-25 | Detention - Torture |
| Mohammad Musa al-Khaled | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | 2014-12-25 | Shooting | |
| Yusri Ali Mahmoud al-Barm | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Giza | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Unidentified | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Sheikh Miskeen | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Mohammad Qatleesh | Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Dael | 2014-12-25 | Shelling |
| Mohammad Yosef Abo Zaid | Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Dael | 2014-12-25 | Shelling |
| Alaa Abo al-Nadr | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Daraya | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ammar Musa al-Hariri | Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Dael | 2014-12-25 | Shelling |
| Mamoun Khaleel al-Tamr al-Jbawi | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Jassim | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Unidentified | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Manbej | 2014-12-25 | Kidnapping - Execution |
| Usama Hawa | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Anadan | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Yousef Ibraheem al-Asad "al-Shaikh Deeb" | Civilian | Adult - Male | Hama | Karnaz | 2014-12-25 | Detention - Torture |
| Omar Ahmad Thalji | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Zakwan Mohammad al-Abes | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Jarjanaz | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Mohammad Abdul Moniem Deebo | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Jarjanaz | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Mohammad Khaled al-Heer | Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Maarat Numan: Deir Sharqee | 2014-12-25 | Detention - Torture |
| Hasan Aboud | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Bsagla | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Mohammad Zaatout | Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus | Yarmuk Camp | 2014-12-25 | Detention - Torture |
| Abo Rabea al-Bukaie | Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Yalda | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Bilal Tareefe | Civilian | Child - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Douma | 2014-12-25 | Other |
| Ghaith Muhi Eddin al-Shazeli | Civilian | Child - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Douma | 2014-12-25 | Shelling |
| Ahmed Darwish | Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Harasta | 2014-12-25 | Chemical and toxic gases |
| Abo Malek al-Masri | Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Harasta | 2014-12-25 | Chemical and toxic gases |
| Ihsan Mahmoud al-Shaeir | Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Kafrshams | 2014-12-25 | Detention - Torture |
| Sobh Mohammad Metiemb al-Aloush | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Harra | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Ali Abdul Ghani Anees | Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus Suburbs | Douma | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Maan Sahl al-Radi | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Daraa | Naseeb | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Abo Obaida al-Ansari | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Homs | Waar | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Majdi Azzam Farhat | Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Binnish | 2014-12-25 | Shelling |
| Unidentified | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Batbo | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Hosain Sayel al-Mostafa | Civilian | Adult - Male | Hama | Kaferzita | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ahmad Khaled Obaid | Civilian | Adult - Male | Hama | Kaferzita | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mahmoud Abd al-Moetei al-Elaiwi | Civilian | Adult - Male | Hama | Shehrnaz | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Hasan Mohammad al-Salloum | Civilian | Child - Male | Hama | Shehrnaz | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mahmoud Mohammad al-Saloum | Civilian | Child - Male | Hama | Shehrnaz | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Abo Sardah | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Damascus | 2014-12-25 | Shooting | |
| Mohammad Taher Wais | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Maher Taleb | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad al-Hasan | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Abo Taha al-Turkmani | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Abo Ibrahem al-Ghawi | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Ahmad Swaid | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Joud al-Ghawi | Civilian | Child - Female | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Futoon Abo Zahed | Civilian | Child - Female | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Hasna Mahmoud al-Sawas | Civilian | Adult - Female | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Fatema al-Sawas | Civilian | Adult - Female | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad Shaker Mehho | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Abdul Ghani Sheikh Ahmad | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Jomaa Qadour | Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified 1 | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified 2 | Civilian | Child - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified 3 | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Unidentified 4 | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Aleppo | Bab | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Shamoun Ali al-Jamous | Civilian | Adult - Male | Homs | Waar | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Abdul Ilah Ramadan al-Alewi | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Homs | Khalidiya | 2014-12-25 | Shooting |
| Unidentified | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Quneitra | 2014-12-25 | Shooting | |
| Wesam Ebraheem al-Eibrahim | Non-Civilian | Adult - Male | Homs | Hula | 2014-12-25 | Shelling |
| Ibraheem Ahmad al-Aytam | Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Ketyan | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Mohammad Hasoun | Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Ketyan | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
| Basem Nadim | Civilian | Adult - Male | Idlib | Ketyan | 2014-12-25 | Warplane shelling |
Thursday, 18 December 2014
This Saturday: Syria vigils in London, Manchester, and online
In the past year, press attention on Syria largely shifted from Assad’s campaign of terror to the terror of ISIS as they first expanded their reach from eastern Syria into northern Iraq, and then went on to lay siege to the largely Kurdish town of Kobane in north Syria, a battle that ranged within sight of Western media across the border in Turkey.
The TV crews have mostly moved on, but the battle for Kobane continues, with Kurdish and Free Syrian Army forces still fighting together to beat back ISIS. And Kobane is not alone: Across Syria towns and villages are fighting for their lives – against ISIS, against the Assad regime, and in some cases against both at the same time.
And while ISIS adopts the Assad regime’s methods of torture and oppression*, the regime goes on killing Syrians on a scale that ISIS still only dreams of**.
In the past few weeks, the Syria’s Forgotten Cities campaign has aimed to raise awareness of the many other Kobanes: focusing on Aleppo, Homs, Raqqa, and remembering the many more, Daraa, Daraya, Deir Ez-Zour, Douma, Hama, Jobar, Idlib, Yarmouk, Zamalka – places battered but not beaten, cities and towns where the fight for freedom and dignity goes on.
As Syrians face another winter of bombing, siege, starvation, and terror, we must resist the temptation to turn away in despair, so we are holding vigils in London and Manchester this Saturday, and we invite you to join us.
LONDON
Saturday 20th December, 6 to 8:00 pm in Trafalgar Square.
Facebook event page.
MANCHESTER
Saturday 20th December, 5 to 6:00 pm in Piccadilly Gardens.
Facebook event page.
Press release PDF.
For anyone unable to be present in either of these two cities, we are also holding an online vigil. Please help show solidarity with Syrians in this fourth winter of war by lighting a candle wherever you are and posting a picture of it on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram, with the hashtag #SyriasForgottenCities. More details here.
* See: Islamic State adopts Assad’s methods of torture, Richard Spencer, The Telegraph, 13 December 2014.
** See: Syrian Network for Human Rights on civilian deaths since the start of the US-led intervention against ISIS in Syria.
Sunday, 14 December 2014
Humanitarian aid is important but won’t stop the war
This is a guest post by Daniel Wickham, and first appeared as a series of tweets.
If we all agree that letting Syria descend into a civil war fought primarily between equally bad actors – the Assad regime on one hand, and extremist groups like ISIS and al-Nusra on the other – is not what we want, doesn’t that make the only logical solution to strengthen those caught in between?
As long as Assad has the upper hand against the mainstream rebels, and the world is distracted by ISIS, the chance of an agreement with a long-term ceasefire seems almost non-existent. That can surely only happen if the Syrian regime faces serious, violent internal pressure to make a deal, or is overthrown either in part or entirely, neither of which is likely to happen unless the mainstream rebels are supported.
That doesn’t mean *any* mainstream rebels, but specifically those who do not target and murder civilians, and can be made to abide by IHL.
Humanitarian aid is important but won’t stop the war, and the current air campaign against ISIS seems to be only strengthening the regime. To stop ISIS, there has to either be a deal followed by concessions or an overthrow of the regime, which is its most effective recruiter. What other way can that happen except through a strengthening of (certain) mainstream rebels and perhaps even an air campaign vs. Assad?
On a personal note, it really pains me to advocate policies like bombing, but I just don’t see how else the slaughter can be stopped/slowed. When it comes to tragedies like Syria, you have to look beyond your own ideological biases and ask what is the best of the bad options? I’ve said this before and been accused of supporting imperialism. But remember, the policy I’m advocating is aggressively opposed by the US.
To be honest though, I couldn’t care less what the US establishment or its opponents think about Syria. The uprising is not about them. It’s about people who are being starved, murdered and besieged simply for wanting to be free from a cowardly and murderous tyrant. And at the end of the day, I’d rather show solidarity with them than fake ‘anti-imperialists’ sitting in the West. A million times over.
If we all agree that letting Syria descend into a civil war fought primarily between equally bad actors – the Assad regime on one hand, and extremist groups like ISIS and al-Nusra on the other – is not what we want, doesn’t that make the only logical solution to strengthen those caught in between?
As long as Assad has the upper hand against the mainstream rebels, and the world is distracted by ISIS, the chance of an agreement with a long-term ceasefire seems almost non-existent. That can surely only happen if the Syrian regime faces serious, violent internal pressure to make a deal, or is overthrown either in part or entirely, neither of which is likely to happen unless the mainstream rebels are supported.
That doesn’t mean *any* mainstream rebels, but specifically those who do not target and murder civilians, and can be made to abide by IHL.
Humanitarian aid is important but won’t stop the war, and the current air campaign against ISIS seems to be only strengthening the regime. To stop ISIS, there has to either be a deal followed by concessions or an overthrow of the regime, which is its most effective recruiter. What other way can that happen except through a strengthening of (certain) mainstream rebels and perhaps even an air campaign vs. Assad?
On a personal note, it really pains me to advocate policies like bombing, but I just don’t see how else the slaughter can be stopped/slowed. When it comes to tragedies like Syria, you have to look beyond your own ideological biases and ask what is the best of the bad options? I’ve said this before and been accused of supporting imperialism. But remember, the policy I’m advocating is aggressively opposed by the US.
To be honest though, I couldn’t care less what the US establishment or its opponents think about Syria. The uprising is not about them. It’s about people who are being starved, murdered and besieged simply for wanting to be free from a cowardly and murderous tyrant. And at the end of the day, I’d rather show solidarity with them than fake ‘anti-imperialists’ sitting in the West. A million times over.
Monday, 8 December 2014
Deter and Retaliate
BUFFER ZONES, SAFE ZONES, AIR-EXCLUSION ZONES
The week from Sunday 30th November to Sunday 7th December started with a lot of words published on the possibility of a no-fly zone in Syria, and ended with a practical demonstration of the feasibility of imposing one. It began with three news stories, all based on leaks or off-record conversations by US officials about ongoing negotiations between retired Marine Gen. John Allen, US special presidential envoy, and Turkish officials on the possibility of establishing a ‘safe zone’ in Northern Syria where civilians and rebels would have a degree of protection from both Assad forces and ISIS.
- From Bloomberg View, 30th November:
Will U.S. and Turkey Create a Syria No-Fly Zone? By Josh Rogin and Eli Lake.
- From the Wall Street Journal, updated 1st December:
U.S., Turkey Narrow Differences on Islamic State Fight, by Adam Entous.
- From The Washington Post, 1st December:
U.S. considers opening new front against Islamic State to create a safe zone in Syria, by Karen DeYoung.
- Colonel Steve Warren, Pentagon spokesperson, 1st December:
“Right now, we don’t believe a buffer zone is the best way to relieve the humanitarian crisis there in northern Syria.”
- Josh Earnest, White House spokesperson, 1st December:
“… At this point, we don’t believe that a no-fly zone fits the bill here.”
- Susan Rice, National Security Advisor to President Obama, 2nd December:
“We are not moving in the direction of a no-fly zone or a safe haven at this point,” and “We think the establishment of a no-fly zone or a safe zone, at this point, is at best premature, and would be a major investment of resources that would be something, frankly, of a diversion from the primary task at hand.”
And then on Sunday the 7th of December Israel again demonstrated how vulnerable the Assad regime is to air attack by carrying out daylight strikes on the outskirts of Damascus.
DETER AND RETALIATE
Worth noting in the three initial news reports about safe zone negotiations is that the plan they describe envisages a no-fly zone maintained by deterrence and retaliation rather than by either air patrol and interception as seen in Bosnia and Iraq in the 1990s, or eradication of regime air assets as seen in Libya in 2011. From the Wall Street Journal version:
In contrast to a formal no-fly zone, the narrower safe zone along the border under discussion wouldn’t require any strikes to take out Syrian air defenses. Instead, the U.S. and its coalition partners could send a quiet warning to the Assad regime to stay away from the zone or risk retaliation.
While there’s an implication in the article that a Deter and Retaliate approach can only work for a limited scale no-fly zone, recent events in Syria suggest that it would work for a no-fly zone over the entire country. Three experiences point to Assad being susceptible to deterrence: his agreement to allow the removal of chemical weapons following the threat of military action; the lack of any military response by Assad to US-led forces carrying out strikes in Syrian territory; and the lack of any direct military response by Assad to Israel’s repeated strikes against his military. Assad clearly knows he is unlikely to survive a direct military conflict with the US or its allies, and will go as far as possible to avoid one. As to retaliation, yesterday’s daylight strikes by Israel against Assad’s military in the Damascus area once again make clear that it is well within the means of the US and its allies to retaliate should Assad defy a no-fly zone.
Finally, how would a Deter and Retaliate no-fly zone work, and why might it be preferable to a patrolled no-fly zone, or to eradicating Assad’s air force?
The US and its allies already have the means to monitor Syrian territory to detect air attacks, and have the means available to retaliate in the event of any attacks taking place, so the next step would be to demand an immediate end to air attacks by Assad’s air force, and declare that any further attacks will be met with a punitive military response. There is a good chance the Assad regime would comply fully with this demand in order not to risk being hit by US strikes. If however the Assad regime decided to test US resolve by carrying out one or more air attacks, the US and its allies would not seek to intercept the particular aircraft violating the no-fly zone; instead they would first verify that an attack had taken place, and then respond with an attack against a target of their choice, for example Assad aircraft on the ground or other similar military targets.
There are major advantages in this Deter and Retaliate approach compared to patrols or eradication. Not engaging in patrolling or interception is safer for air crews. Avoiding the wide-scale strikes needed to eradicate Assad’s air force lowers the risk of unintended civilian casualties as well as lowering risk to air crews. And of course avoiding patrols and wide-scale strikes also makes Deter and Retaliate cheaper. It could cost as little as a phone call.
There would be three justifications for declaring such a no-fly zone. One, as with earlier chemical attacks by Assad forces, the regime’s deliberate targeting of civilian areas blatantly contravenes established international humanitarian law. Two, United Nations Security Council Resolution 2139, passed in February, demanded an end to such attacks. Three, such attacks hamper efforts by the US and its allies to combat ISIS.
RELATED POSTS
- Stop the barrel bombs: A moral and legal responsibility to use force
- Seven months on: Enforce UNSCR 2139
- Obama’s Syria menu: Where’s the No-Fly Zone?
- No-Fly Zone options: Reasons for favouring a limited strike option
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




